Cultural Trend Report: BIPOC & Women Viewers and Responsible True Crime Content
TLDR: BIPOC viewers are increasingly demanding true crime and historical narrative content that goes beyond sensationalism and "trauma porn." There's a growing preference for responsible journalism that not only retells stories but unveils new information, challenges existing narratives, and provokes action. This shift reflects a broader trend of BIPOC audiences seeking empowerment, representation, and social change through media consumption.
Key Points:
From Trauma to Empowerment: BIPOC viewers are rejecting content that solely focuses on their communities' pain and instead seeking narratives that highlight resilience, justice-seeking, and systemic change.
Unveiling New Information: There's a strong demand for content that doesn't just rehash known facts but provides new insights, perspectives, or evidence.
Provoking Action: Viewers want content that not only informs but also inspires social action and change.
Intersectional Storytelling: There's growing interest in narratives that explore the complexities of identity and how various forms of oppression intersect.
Responsible Representation: BIPOC audiences are calling for more nuanced, authentic portrayals of their communities in true crime and historical content.
Could True Crime Be an Unexpected Gateway to Social Justice Issues?
The Belmont Agency strategists have identified that true crime's popularity in American media stems from factors like curiosity about criminal motivations, interest in justice, and the thrill of solving real-life mysteries, often providing escapism through a satisfying narrative structure. While true crime's universal themes and emotional distance contribute to its appeal over social justice content, recent studies show that true crime podcast listeners are more likely to engage actively with cases, such as providing tips or signing petitions.
Interestingly, true crime media has inadvertently become a gateway to broader social justice issues, exposing consumers to systemic problems within the criminal justice system, racial disparities, and socioeconomic factors contributing to crime. This unintended consequence is transforming true crime from mere entertainment into a catalyst for awareness and activism, fostering a more socially conscious audience and bridging the gap between passive entertainment and active engagement with pressing social justice concerns.
Case Study 1: Redefining True Crime Narratives
The true crime genre is undergoing a significant transformation, particularly in how it approaches stories involving BIPOC individuals and communities. There's a shift away from sensationalized accounts that risk re-traumatizing communities towards more nuanced, contextual storytelling.
Example: The success of "When They See Us" (2019) demonstrated the power of retelling a well-known story (the Central Park Five case) with new perspectives and a focus on systemic injustice.
Example: The controversy surrounding the "Dahmer" series on Netflix (2022) highlighted the ongoing debate about the ethics of true crime storytelling and the importance of centering victims' and families' perspectives.
Example: The podcast "Crime Junkie" faced significant backlash in 2019 for plagiarism and insensitive handling of cases involving BIPOC victims. Their approach was criticized for prioritizing entertainment over respectful, well-researched storytelling, leading to accusations of exploiting traumatic events for profit.
Case Study 2: Unveiling Hidden Histories
BIPOC viewers are increasingly drawn to content that uncovers lesser-known aspects of historical events or provides new insights into well-known stories. This trend reflects a desire to challenge dominant historical narratives and bring marginalized perspectives to the forefront.
Example: The renewed interest in the Menendez brothers' case, partly driven by social media activism, has led to reexaminations of the role of childhood trauma and abuse in high-profile crimes.
Example: Documentaries like "Summer of Soul" (2021) have garnered acclaim for bringing to light overlooked moments in Black cultural history.
Example: The 2019 film "Green Book" won the Oscar for Best Picture but was widely criticized by many BIPOC viewers and critics. Despite attempting to tell a story about race relations, it was seen as perpetuating a white savior narrative and oversimplifying complex racial issues, failing to provide new insights or perspectives on the Civil Rights era.
Case Study 3: Activism Through Viewership
There's a growing recognition among BIPOC audiences of the power of their viewership choices. Many are actively seeking out and supporting content that aligns with their values and desire for social change.
Example: The widespread support for Ava DuVernay's work, including "13th" (2016) and "When They See Us," demonstrates the appetite for content that explicitly connects historical injustices to contemporary issues.
Example: The success of "Pose" (2018-2021) showed the demand for content that celebrates BIPOC LGBTQ+ experiences while also addressing historical and ongoing challenges.
Example: The initial marketing campaign for the 2020 film "Antebellum" was criticized for its misleading trailers and promotional materials. Many viewers felt the marketing sensationalized Black trauma for shock value, leading to disappointment and frustration when the film failed to deliver meaningful commentary on racial issues.
Case Study 4: Intersectional Storytelling
BIPOC viewers are increasingly interested in content that explores the complexities of identity and how various forms of oppression intersect. This reflects a broader cultural shift towards more nuanced understandings of race, gender, sexuality, and class.
Example: The popularity of shows like "Lovecraft Country" (2020) demonstrated the appetite for content that blends genre storytelling with explorations of race and history.
Example: The critical acclaim for "I May Destroy You" (2020) highlighted the desire for stories that address complex issues of consent, race, and trauma in nuanced ways.
Example: The 2017 film "Detroit" was criticized for its portrayal of historical racial violence. Despite attempts to address a significant moment in Black history, many felt the film, directed by Kathryn Bigelow (a white director), failed to adequately contextualize the events or provide a nuanced perspective on race relations, instead focusing primarily on graphic depictions of violence against Black individuals.
Case Study 5: Responsible Representation Behind the Scenes
There's growing awareness and demand for BIPOC representation not just on screen but in all aspects of production. Viewers are becoming more conscious of who is telling these stories and how that impacts the final product.
Example: The success of Ryan Murphy's "Pose," which employed many LGBTQ+ and BIPOC individuals both in front of and behind the camera, set a new standard for authentic storytelling.
Example: The controversy surrounding the initial lack of BIPOC journalists in the newsroom covering the Gabby Petito case highlighted the importance of diverse perspectives in true crime reporting.
Example: The 2016 film "Stonewall" faced significant backlash for whitewashing the Stonewall riots, a pivotal moment in LGBTQ+ history led by trans women of color. The decision to center the story on a fictional white, cisgender male protagonist was seen as erasing the contributions of BIPOC LGBTQ+ individuals, leading to calls for boycotts and widespread criticism of the film's marketing and production choices.
Audience Data & Viewing Habits
All sources cited at the end of this document.
Psychological and Forensic Insights: True crime consumers are highly interested in understanding the psychology behind criminal events (49%) and the forensic science involved (48%). They are drawn to the mental processes of criminals and the scientific methods used to solve crimes. (Source: Edison Research and audiochuck study, 2024)
Interactive Engagement: True crime podcast listeners show a strong preference for content that allows them to participate actively. They enjoy solving mysteries (50%) and are more likely to engage in case-related activities such as providing tips to help solve cases or signing petitions. (Sources: Edison Research and audiochuck study, 2024; Pew Research Center study, 2022)
Narrative-Driven Content: Consumers prefer true crime content that follows a satisfying narrative structure, often with elements of suspense and thrill (50%). This preference aligns with the popularity of serialized podcasts and long-form investigative content. (Source: Edison Research and audiochuck study, 2024)
Multitasking-Friendly Format: A significant majority (84%) of true crime podcast listeners appreciate having something to listen to while doing other activities. This suggests a preference for audio formats that allow for passive consumption during daily tasks. (Source: Pew Research Center study, 2022)
Female-Oriented Content: Women, especially those with lower levels of formal education, show a much stronger preference for true crime content. Among podcast listeners, 44% of women regularly listen to true crime podcasts compared to 23% of men, indicating a need for content that resonates with female audiences. (Source: Pew Research Center study, 2022)
Conclusion & Assumptions
The true crime genre is undergoing a significant transformation, driven largely by the evolving preferences and demands of BIPOC viewers. This shift reflects broader cultural movements towards empowerment, authenticity, and social justice. BIPOC and Woman audiences are increasingly rejecting "trauma porn" in favor of content that not only entertains but also educates, empowers, and inspires action. There's a growing demand for responsible storytelling that goes beyond retelling known facts, instead unveiling new information and challenging existing narratives.
The call for authentic representation extends beyond on-screen portrayals to behind-the-scenes roles, with viewers becoming increasingly conscious of who is telling these stories. Content that explores intersectionality and the complexities of identity is gaining traction, while true crime is inadvertently becoming a gateway to broader social justice issues. Looking ahead, content creators and platforms that can meet these demands for responsible, provocative, and informative storytelling are likely to find engaged and passionate audiences.
For studios and content streaming platforms, this presents both a challenge and an opportunity to set new industry standards for ethical storytelling and diverse representation. Ultimately, the future of true crime content lies in its ability to not just captivate audiences, but to contribute meaningfully to ongoing conversations about justice, equality, and social change. As BIPOC viewers continue to shape this genre, we can expect to see more nuanced, impactful, and socially conscious storytelling in the years to come.
Learn More | Read Our Sources
Edison Research. (2024, September 12). The True Crime Consumer Report by Edison Research and audiochuck. https://www.edisonresearch.com/the-true-crime-consumer-report-by-edison-research-and-audiochuck/
Brody, R. (2017, August 1). The immoral artistry of Kathryn Bigelow's "Detroit". The New Yorker. https://www.newyorker.com/culture/richard-brody/the-immoral-artistry-of-kathryn-bigelows-detroit
Edison Research. (n.d.). The True Crime Consumer Report by Edison Research and audiochuck. https://www.edisonresearch.com/the-true-crime-consumer-report-by-edison-research-and-audiochuck/
Geier, T. (2018, November 29). Green Book is a good version of an outdated kind of movie. We Minored in Film. https://weminoredinfilm.com/2018/11/29/green-book-is-a-good-version-of-an-outdated-kind-of-movie/
Grady, C. (2019, February 19). Green Book is a Best Picture frontrunner. Should it be? Vox. https://www.vox.com/culture/2019/2/19/18222085/green-book-oscars-2019-best-picture-win-lose-controversy
Grady, C. (2020, August 17). A guide to Lovecraft Country's many pop culture tropes and references. Vox. https://www.vox.com/culture/21348900/lovecraft-country-references-whitey-on-the-moon-episode-2
Nussbaum, E. (2019, June 24). How "When They See Us" and "Chernobyl" make us look. The New Yorker. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/06/24/how-when-they-see-us-and-chernobyl-make-us-look
Orenstein, M. (2015, August 24). Whitewashing Stonewall. Prindle Institute for Ethics. https://www.prindleinstitute.org/2015/08/stonewall-draft/
Pearce, M. (2023, June 20). True crime podcasts are popular in the U.S., particularly among women and those with less formal education. Pew Research Center. https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/06/20/true-crime-podcasts-are-popular-in-the-us-particularly-among-women-and-those-with-less-formal-education/
Perrie, W. (2020, October 17). Review: Lovecraft Country is a cleverly subversive take that (mostly) works. Ars Technica. https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2020/10/review-genre-hopping-lovecraft-country-is-a-wild-ride-that-mostly-works/
Salam, M. (2021, June 3). How Pose changed Hollywood forever. Harper's Bazaar. https://www.harpersbazaar.com/culture/features/a36537121/pose-finale-digital-cover/
Smallwood, C. (2019, June 3). When They See Us and the persistent logic of 'No Humans Involved'. The Atlantic. https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2019/06/when-they-see-us-and-persistent-language-black-criminality/590695/
Spiegel, R. (2023, June 15). "Pose" actor launches talent agency to support BIPOC queer and trans performers. Gay City News. https://gaycitynews.com/pose-actor-launches-talent-agency-to-support-queer-and-trans-performers-of-color/
Sreenivasan, H. (2019, May 31). Ava DuVernay does true crime differently in When They See Us. The Atlantic. https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2019/05/when-they-see-us-review-netflix/590371/
Sugrue, T. J. (2017, August 4). Why Detroit erupted. Slate. https://slate.com/business/2017/08/tom-sugrue-on-what-the-movie-detroit-gets-right-and-wrong.html
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. (2024, January 11). Why are we fascinated by true crime? https://www.unc.edu/posts/2024/01/11/why-are-we-fascinated-by-true-crime/
YouGov. (n.d.). True crime: How does the genre affect Americans? https://today.yougov.com/entertainment/articles/50142-true-crime-how-it-affects-americans